Skip to content
Kamil JK

Discourse

Definition

Discourse is not simply language or text, but a system of thought, knowledge, and power that determines what can be said, thought, or perceived as truth within specific historical and social contexts. It operates in liminal spaces between power and resistance, knowledge and ignorance, subject and object—simultaneously constructing reality while concealing its own constructedness.

Liminal Modality

Discourse functions precisely at threshold zones where:

  • Sayable ↔ Unsayable: Defining boundaries of legitimate speech and thought
  • Visible ↔ Invisible: Determining what can be perceived or recognized
  • Subject ↔ Object: Constituting both speaking subjects and objects of knowledge
  • Power ↔ Resistance: Creating the conditions for both control and subversion

These boundary operations make discourse inherently liminal—always working at the edges of established knowledge systems.

Key Attributes

◎ Power-Knowledge Nexus

Discourse both produces and is produced by power relations, creating regimes of truth that determine what is considered legitimate knowledge. Power operates not just as repression but as productive force through discourse.

“Power produces reality; it produces domains of objects and rituals of truth.” — Foucault

⌛ Historical Contingency

Discursive formations are not universal but emerge from specific historical and cultural contexts, often shifting dramatically across different epistemes (historical knowledge systems).

⛓️ Institutional Reinforcement

Discourses are maintained through institutions (medical, legal, educational, media) that validate certain statements while excluding others. These institutions regulate who can speak with authority and on what topics.

⟲ Subject Formation

Discourse doesn’t simply express pre-existing subjects but actively constitutes them, creating subject positions from which individuals can speak and be recognized.

⊖ Exclusionary Practices

Every discourse operates through rules of exclusion determining what cannot be said, who cannot speak, and which statements are rejected as false, dangerous, or meaningless.

Discursive Structures & Mechanisms

Discursive Formations

Patterns and rules governing what statements can emerge within a particular knowledge domain.

Key elements include:

  • Objects: What can be spoken about
  • Enunciative Modalities: Who can speak with authority
  • Concepts: How ideas can be organized and related
  • Strategies: How knowledge can be deployed for various purposes

Statement Function

The statement (énoncé) as fundamental unit of discourse operates not through meaning but function—how it relates to other statements, institutions, and practices.

Archives

The system defining the emergence and transformation of statements, functioning as the “law of what can be said” within a given period.

Discursive Practices

Activities that systematically form the objects they speak about, not merely representing but actively producing reality.

Threshold Dynamics

Discourse operates through critical threshold operations:

  1. Rarefaction
    Mechanisms that limit who can speak and what can be said:

    • Commentary (privileging certain “primary” texts)
    • Author function (attributing unity and authority)
    • Disciplines (defining methodological boundaries)

  2. Discontinuity
    Points where discursive shifts create ruptures in knowledge systems:

    • Epistemic breaks (fundamental reorganizations of knowledge)
    • Paradigm shifts (reorientations of scientific understanding)
    • Discursive transformations (changes in what counts as evidence)

  3. Materialization
    How discourse becomes embedded in:

    • Bodies (through disciplinary practices)
    • Architecture (through spatial arrangements)
    • Technologies (through design and implementation)
    • Institutions (through policies and procedures)

Types of Discourse Analysis

Different approaches to analyzing discursive formations:

Archaeology

Examines the historical conditions making certain statements possible, focusing on rules governing discursive practices rather than meanings or intentions.

Genealogy

Traces how discourses emerge from power relations and historical contingencies, rejecting notions of inevitable progress or origin.

Critical Discourse Analysis

Analyzes how social power, dominance, and inequality are reproduced through text and talk in social and political contexts.

Performative Analysis

Explores how discourse doesn’t just describe but performs social actions, bringing realities into being through speech acts.

Discourse in Liminal Spaces

Discourse has special properties in liminal zones:

Contested Terrains

Areas where multiple discourses compete for legitimacy:

  • Scientific controversies
  • Emergent technologies
  • Social movements
  • Cultural boundaries

Discursive Hybridity

Zones where discourses mix and transform:

  • Interdisciplinary spaces
  • Cultural contact zones
  • Translation contexts
  • Digital/physical interfaces

Silences & Gaps

Where discourse reveals its limits:

  • Taboo subjects
  • Traumatic experiences
  • Ineffable phenomena
  • Structural exclusions

Applications & Analytical Utility

Institutional Analysis

Examining how organizations establish and maintain regimes of truth through:

  • Mission statements and policies
  • Classification systems
  • Standard operating procedures
  • Evaluation criteria

Media Studies

Analyzing how public discourse is shaped through:

  • Framing techniques
  • Source selection
  • Narrative conventions
  • Visual rhetoric

Policy Analysis

Understanding how issues are constituted through:

  • Problem definitions
  • Causal narratives
  • Target population constructions
  • Solution frameworks

Identity Politics

Exploring how subjectivities are formed through:

  • Naming practices
  • Categorization systems
  • Recognition policies
  • Resistance narratives

Discourse and Resistance

Points where discourse creates possibilities for resistance:

Counter-Discourse

Alternative knowledge systems that challenge dominant narratives:

  • Indigenous knowledge traditions
  • Feminist epistemologies
  • Subaltern historiographies
  • Queer theory

Discursive Tactics

Strategic interventions within dominant discourses:

  • Appropriation and recontextualization
  • Parody and subversion
  • Strategic silence
  • Rhetorical jujitsu

Discursive Ruptures

Moments where established discourses break down:

  • Crisis events
  • Paradigm collapses
  • Revolutionary periods
  • Technological disruptions
  • Power: The productive force operating through and alongside discourse
  • Truth: Not objective reality but what discourse establishes as true
  • Regimes of Truth: Systems determining what counts as true/false
  • Semantics: Linguistic meaning-making within discursive systems
  • Knowledge: Products of discursive formations rather than neutral discovery
  • Subjectivation: How subjects are formed through discourse
  • Resistance: Counter-forces emerging within discursive systems

Further Reading